Episode #147: How To Get Good Ideas

Many professionals feel frustrated when their good ideas meet only rejection or harsh criticism. In some corporate cultures — even at major global brands — confrontation is seen as strength. Meeting rooms turn into “Confrontation Rooms,” where new proposals are shredded instead of shaped.

While such environments may produce tough survivors, they also bury countless creative possibilities. Employees learn to stay silent rather than risk ridicule. The result: innovation stagnates.

Summary: Fear-driven environments kill creativity before it can begin.

Organizations that reward aggression may believe they are cultivating strong, “Darwinian” thinkers. Yet this outdated mindset ignores how modern teams thrive — through inclusion, psychological safety, and collaborative idea-building.

When leaders confuse competition with creativity, valuable voices are lost. Some of the deepest thinkers hold back, knowing their thoughtful ideas will be dismissed in public debates. The organization suffers, and so does its long-term potential.

Summary: Combative cultures breed caution, not creativity.

At Dale Carnegie, we teach the importance of separating two stages in innovation:

• Green Light Thinking — free-flowing idea generation without judgment.

• Red Light Thinking — structured evaluation and refinement.

Mixing these stages is destructive. Critiquing ideas during the Green Light stage stops creativity in its tracks. Once people feel safe to share freely, even “crazy” ideas can inspire practical breakthroughs.

Summary: Separate idea creation (Green Light) from evaluation (Red Light) to maximize innovation.

Executives and managers must model inclusive behavior — allowing every voice to be heard without fear. Encourage brainstorming sessions where judgment is suspended. Protect contributors from criticism during early stages.

This approach stimulates cross-pollination — when one idea sparks another — creating a dynamic cycle of innovation. By shifting from confrontation to collaboration, leaders build teams that generate more, better, and bolder ideas.

Summary: Safe spaces for expression lead to stronger business innovation.

• Separate creative (Green Light) and evaluative (Red Light) stages.

• Encourage open participation — every “imperfect” idea is valuable.

• Replace confrontation with collaboration to unlock team potential.

• Build an inclusive, psychologically safe culture that drives innovation.

Founded in the U.S. in 1912, Dale Carnegie Training has been empowering professionals around the world for more than a century in the areas of leadership, sales, presentations, executive coaching, and DEI.
Our Tokyo office, established in 1963, continues to support both Japanese and multinational companies through world-class programs in leadership training, sales training, presentation training, and executive coaching.