Love Your B Players — A Pragmatic Talent Strategy for SMB Leaders in Japan
Why isn’t “hire only A Players” realistic for most companies?
A-Player hiring works when you have big-tech budgets. Smaller firms in Tokyo and across Japan don’t. Overpaying a few stars concentrates risk, strains cash flow, and invites poaching.
Mini-summary: For most SMBs, the “A-Players-everywhere” mantra is a mirage.
What’s the strategic value of B Players?
B Players are capable, consistent, and profitable. Their revenue-to-cost multiple is often healthier than that of expensive stars demanding raises. A strong bench of B Players reduces key-person risk.
Mini-summary: B Players compound performance without concentration risk.
Should we still develop C Players?
Yes—C → B is the highest-ROI path. Use targeted training (sales, presentation, leadership), tight coaching cadences, and clear role scorecards. Reserve heavy investment for those showing momentum.
Mini-summary: Systematically lift C to B; be selective about pushing B to A.
How do we decide how much to invest? (The “Multiple” model)
Track each salesperson’s fully loaded cost (salary, benefits, enablement, overhead) vs. attributable gross margin.
-
Productivity Multiple = Attributable GM ÷ Fully Loaded Cost
-
Manage two dials: (1) absolute volume to protect cash; (2) multiple to protect efficiency.
-
Set guardrails (e.g., minimum volume floor + minimum multiple target).
Mini-summary: Balance volume and efficiency; invest where multiples are improving.
What about the risk of losing newly minted A Players?
Mitigate poaching and fragility by:
-
Process > person: playbooks, shared accounts, CRM hygiene, recorded call libraries.
-
Team quotas & rewards: blend individual + team incentives.
-
Career lattice: advanced paths (coach, enablement lead, strategic accounts) without only pay inflation.
Mini-summary: De-risk stardom with systems, sharing, and career alternatives.
How should leaders handle star departures?
Own the narrative immediately. Explain it’s a personal choice, reaffirm strategy and pipeline, and highlight bench strength. Silence breeds rumors that spook remaining talent and clients.
Mini-summary: Transparent communication preserves confidence and retention.
What concrete development path turns B into “your best B+”?
-
Skills: Sales training, presentation training, executive-presence coaching.
-
Rhythm: Weekly pipeline 1:1s, monthly skills coaching, quarterly capability goals.
-
Toolkit: Deal review templates, proposal libraries, win-loss debriefs, demo scripts.
-
Recognition: Public wins, micro-bonuses tied to multiple improvement, peer mentoring roles.
Mini-summary: Structure + coaching + recognition = durable performance lift.
Key Takeaways
-
The all-A-Player dream is cash-intensive and risky for SMBs.
-
B Players deliver stable volume and healthy multiples.
-
Track volume and multiple; invest where both move up.
-
Systematize knowledge to reduce star fragility and poaching risk.
-
Communicate departures fast; protect morale and clients.
About Dale Carnegie Tokyo
Request a Free Consultation to design a B-Player–first talent system (sales training, presentation skills, executive coaching) tailored to Japanese SMB realities.
Founded in the U.S. in 1912, Dale Carnegie Training has supported individuals and companies worldwide for over a century in leadership, sales, presentation, executive coaching, and DEI. Our Tokyo office, established in 1963, has been empowering both Japanese and multinational corporate clients ever since.